HDL Cholesterol: Why “Good” Doesn’t Always Mean Protective

Most of us have been taught a simple rule when we look at our cholesterol test results or are told we have high cholesterol:

• LDL cholesterol = bad cholesterol
  
• HDL cholesterol = good cholesterol
  
• Higher HDL is better
  
  

This simple view of good and bad cholesterol sounds logical, but modern research shows it doesn’t tell the whole story.

HDL cholesterol is important, but the number on your blood test doesn’t always reflect how protective it really is, particularly in people with high cholesterol, insulin resistance or inflammation.

‍

HDL cholesterol: why function matters more than numbers

HDL’s main role is to help remove excess cholesterol from tissues and blood vessel walls and return it to the liver for reuse or removal. This process is often described as cholesterol recycling or clean-up.

So the key question isn’t:

How high is my HDL cholesterol?

It’s:

How well is my HDL doing its job?

A standard cholesterol test measures HDL-C, which is simply the amount of cholesterol being carried inside HDL particles. It does not measure how effective those particles are at removing cholesterol from where it causes harm.

This is one reason why people can have normal cholesterol levels on paper, yet still carry cardiovascular risk.

‍

The hidden driver of HDL function: ApoA1

HDL particles work because of the proteins on their surface, not because of the cholesterol they carry.

The most important of these proteins is Apolipoprotein A1 (ApoA1).

ApoA1 acts like the engine and docking system of HDL. It allows HDL to:

• Collect cholesterol from cells and artery walls
  
• Package it safely
  
• Deliver it back to the liver
  
  

Without enough functional ApoA1, HDL cannot do its job properly, regardless of how “good” the HDL number looks.

This helps explain why simply trying to increase HDL cholesterol does not always improve heart health.

‍

Not all HDL particles are the same

HDL particles vary in size and structure, and they do not all carry the same number or quality of ApoA1 proteins.

• Some HDL particles carry more ApoA1 engines and work efficiently
  
• Others carry fewer, or damaged, ApoA1 proteins and are far less effective
  
  

This means two people can have the same HDL cholesterol level, and even a similar cholesterol HDL ratio, but very different levels of cardiovascular protection.

In short: HDL quantity is not the same as HDL quality.

‍

When “good cholesterol” stops being protective

HDL can lose its protective effects in certain conditions, including:

• Chronic inflammation
  
• Insulin resistance or type 2 diabetes
  
• Smoking
  
• Long-term stress
  
• Autoimmune or inflammatory illness
  
  

In these situations, ApoA1 can become damaged or altered. HDL particles may still carry cholesterol, but they struggle to remove it from artery walls effectively.

Clinically, this helps explain why some people with high HDL cholesterol still develop cardiovascular disease, particularly when LDL cholesterol or inflammation is also elevated.

‍

Why raising HDL cholesterol hasn’t reduced heart attacks

Several large studies have tested drugs that successfully raised HDL cholesterol levels.

The result?

• HDL numbers went up
• Heart attack risk did not go down

Why? Because these drugs increased the amount of cholesterol inside HDL particles, not the function of the particles themselves or the effectiveness of ApoA1.

More HDL on a blood test did not mean better HDL function in reality, and it did not improve outcomes for people with high cholesterol.

‍

What HDL really reflects

HDL works best when the body’s internal environment supports it:

• Low inflammation
• Good blood sugar control
• Regular physical activity
• Good sleep
• Minimal smoking and ultra-processed foods
  
  

HDL function improves when overall metabolic health improves, not when we focus only on numbers or follow a low cholesterol diet without addressing lifestyle factors.

‍

The bottom line

HDL cholesterol is not automatically “good.”

It is only protective when it is functional.

A high HDL level may be beneficial, but it should never be viewed in isolation or as a guarantee of protection, especially when LDL cholesterol or other risk markers are elevated.

‍

How to interpret your HDL result

If your HDL is low

• May suggest reduced capacity to remove cholesterol
• Often linked to inactivity, insulin resistance, inflammation or smoking
• It is a signal to improve lifestyle and metabolic health, not just focus on how to increase HDL cholesterol

If your HDL is normal

• Generally reassuring
• Protection still depends on inflammation, blood sugar and overall risk profile
• HDL should be interpreted alongside LDL cholesterol, non-HDL cholesterol and other markers, not alone

If your HDL is high

• May be beneficial, but it is not a guarantee
  
• High HDL does not cancel out high LDL cholesterol, ApoB, inflammation or insulin resistance
  
• In some people, HDL may be high but less functional

‍

What your HDL test does not tell you

A standard cholesterol test does not show:

• How effectively HDL removes cholesterol from artery walls
• How many ApoA1 proteins are present on HDL particles
• Whether HDL is acting in an anti- or pro-inflammatory way
  

It also does not fully reflect how HDL and non-HDL cholesterol interact in determining cardiovascular risk.

‍

A simple way to think about it

HDL cholesterol tells you how much cholesterol is being carried, not how well cholesterol is being cleared.

For meaningful cardiovascular protection, HDL needs to work, not just look good on a blood test.

‍

Key takeaway

HDL cholesterol measures cholesterol transport, not cholesterol clearance. True cardiovascular protection depends on HDL function, ApoA1 integrity, balanced LDL cholesterol levels, and overall metabolic health, not HDL numbers alone.

‍

References (for further reading)

Sarkar S, et al. Journal of Lipid Research. 2024;65:100686. Demonstrates that HDL’s protective function depends on protein composition, not just cholesterol levels.

High Density Lipoprotein Function and Cardiovascular Risk: A Review. PubMed. 2025. Summarises evidence that HDL function and ApoA1 activity predict cardiovascular protection better than HDL-C alone.